Philadelphia Tomato Pie is a beloved local specialty that offers a unique twist on traditional pizza. Unlike the cheesy, topping-loaded pies most people are familiar with, this regional dish from Philadelphia is all about the bold simplicity of bread and tomato sauce.
At its core, tomato pie features a thick, focaccia-like crust that is soft and chewy. It is baked until golden and then generously topped with a rich, slow-cooked tomato sauce. The sauce is the star of the show – bright, tangy, slightly sweet, and seasoned with herbs like oregano and basil. While some versions may include a light dusting of grated Romano or Parmesan cheese, most stay true to the classic approach and skip the cheese entirely.
What makes this dish even more interesting is how it is served. Tomato pie is typically eaten at room temperature, making it a staple at bakeries, Italian markets, and family gatherings. Sliced into squares, it is a popular choice for parties and celebrations, offering a satisfying bite without the mess of melted cheese or greasy toppings.
This style of pizza traces its roots back to Italian immigrants who settled in Philadelphia, bringing with them old-world baking traditions. Over time, the tomato pie became a symbol of community and comfort, a dish that feels just as appropriate at a Sunday dinner as it does at a casual get-together.
Philadelphia Tomato Pie is a reminder that simple ingredients, when prepared with care, can create something truly special. It is a dish that does not try to impress with extravagance but wins you over with its hearty texture and bold, clean flavors. Whether you are a local or just visiting, a slice of tomato pie is a must-try experience.
Ingredients
- 2 1/4 teaspoons active dry yeast
- 1 teaspoon sugar
- 1 1/2 cups warm water about 105°F
- 4 cups all-purpose flour
- 1 teaspoon salt
- 2 tablespoons olive oil plus more for greasing
- 1 can crushed tomatoes 28 ounces
- 2 cloves garlic minced
- 1 tablespoon sugar for sauce
- 1 teaspoon dried oregano
- 1 teaspoon dried basil
- 1/4 teaspoon salt for sauce
- 1/4 teaspoon black pepper
Instructions
- In a large bowl, combine yeast, sugar, and warm water. Let sit for about 5-10 minutes until foamy.
- Add flour, salt, and olive oil to the yeast mixture. Knead until a smooth dough forms, about 10 minutes.
- Place dough in a greased bowl, cover, and let rise until doubled in size, about 1 to 1.5 hours.
- Preheat the oven to 475°F (245°C). Grease a baking sheet or pizza pan.
- Punch down dough and spread it onto the prepared pan, forming a thick edge crust.
- In a medium saucepan, combine crushed tomatoes, garlic, sugar, oregano, basil, salt, and pepper. Simmer for about 15 minutes.
- Spread the tomato sauce evenly over the crust. Allow it to sit for about 5 minutes to soak in.
- Bake in the preheated oven for about 15-20 minutes or until the crust is golden brown.
- Let cool slightly before slicing and serving.
Nutrition
Too many steps, I ain’t got time for that! 😩
Really simple and quick to make! I added some jalapeños for a kick. Yum!
That sounds delicious! I’m definitely trying the jalapeños next time. Thanks for the tip!
Jalapeños in a pie? That just sounds weird, lol. I don’t think that’s the way to do it.
I forgot to add the sugar in the dough and it still turned out great! Cooking is an adventure!
I don’t know about this… tomato pie? Isn’t that just pizza without cheese? 🤔
Just ok. The crust was kinda hard and the sauce didn’t taste like much. Boring! 😒
The dough was too sticky and I couldn’t get it right. Maybe I did something wrong? Not sure if I’ll try again.
It sounds like you might have added too much water or didn’t knead enough. Don’t give up, just adjust the flour a little next time. It’s so worth it!
Ugh, sticky doughs suck! I get it. I always mess it up when there’s too much yeast. Just try again, you’ll nail it for sure!
This is the best tomato pie ever! I made it for my family and everyone loved it. Will definitely make again!
Delicious! My kids couldn’t stop eating it. Perfect for lunch. Gonna try with different toppings next time.
Tasty! Reminds me of my childhood in Philly. Thanks for sharing this recipe!
Glad you enjoyed it! Philly has the best food memories. 🍕
Looks good, but is it really as good as they say? I don’t know about that…
Meh, the crust was too thick for my taste. I prefer a thinner style.
Maybe I’m doing something wrong, but my crust turned out kinda hard… 😞
Maybe you kneaded it too much? Sometimes that makes it tougher. 🤔
I was skeptical at first, but this was surprisingly good. Who knew yeasted crust could work for pizza?
Made this last night and it came out way better than I expected—crispy edges and that quick tomato sauce is legit. Definitely saving this.
Made this last night—super good! The thick edge crust is exactly what I wanted, and the sauce tastes like it actually has depth (garlic + herbs really do the trick). Would bake a minute less next time so it stays softer.
Love hearing this! The crust thick edge is my favorite part too—thanks for the tip about baking a minute less!
Way too much flour for the amount of water in my opinion. I ended up adding a splash more warm water because it wouldn’t knead smooth. Not bad once fixed.
Delish. Also the instructions are actually clear (rare!). Will make again for sure.
I don’t know… it just didn’t taste like pizza to me. The crust was too thick and the sauce was too sweet. Not a fan.
Garlic in the sauce is good, but it could use more herbs. Also I think 4 cups flour might be too much—dough felt stiff for me.
Instructions are fine but 475°F is insane lol. I burned the edge slightly even though I watched it. I’d lower to like 450°F next time.
I agree—475°F seems like overkill for something that only bakes 15–20 mins. I went 450 and it came out way less burnt around the edges.
My sauce tasted flat at first. I think 1 tablespoon sugar was not enough for my tomatoes—added another pinch and it fixed it.
I’m skeptical about this much yeast and that short bake time—mine didn’t get as golden as the picture would suggest. Could be my oven.
I half followed the recipe and it still turned out great! Next time I’ll actually read it all!
I’m glad it turned out great! Sometimes recipes can be a bit overwhelming. Happy cooking next time!
The dough was a little sticky for me even after kneading ~10 minutes, but I added a splash more flour and it worked. Flavor is comforting.
Not sure if I’m doing something wrong, but my crust didn’t really rise to double—maybe my yeast was old? Ended up with a thinner crust. Flavor was okay.
Ok so I may have mixed up the salt for the dough vs the sauce… it was still edible lol. The garlic + oregano combo is definitely the star.
Not bad, but I wish there was cheese in it. It’s like eating tomato sauce on bread without the reward.
Meh. Mine came out bland and I couldn’t really tell the difference from basic pizza sauce. The crust was okay but not wow.
Lol “active dry yeast + warm water about 105°F” — I don’t own a thermometer so I just guessed. It still foamed so I guess I’m a genius.
I totally do the same thing and it usually works. If the water feels “hot tap” not “bath,” I’m good. “Genius” maybe, but definitely lucky 😂
Honestly, that foamy proof is the best thermometer 😄 105°F sounds perfect, but yeast is pretty forgiving if it’s warm-not-hot. Nice work!
This is not a ‘real’ pie!!! Where’s the cheese? Just tomato on bread… I don’t get it.
It’s called a Tomato Pie for a reason! Cheese is not a must. It’s delish as is!
I added some mozzarella cheese on top and it was a game changer! So cheesy and yummy! 😋