Irish apple cake is a traditional dessert that captures the cozy essence of home baking. With its tender crumb, juicy apple slices, and subtle spice, it’s a cake that feels comforting and familiar, yet distinctively Irish. Often served with warm custard or a dusting of powdered sugar, this humble treat is perfect for teatime, brunch, or as a simple dessert that highlights the natural sweetness of apples.
What sets Irish apple cake apart is its rustic texture and balance of flavors. Unlike more refined cakes, it’s slightly dense, with a buttery crumb that supports generous layers of sliced apples. Granny Smith or Bramley apples are often used for their tartness, which contrasts beautifully with the sweetness of the batter. As the cake bakes, the apples soften and release their juices, creating moist pockets of flavor throughout each slice.
A hint of spice – typically cinnamon, nutmeg, or cloves – adds warmth without overpowering the apple’s freshness. Some recipes also include a handful of oats or chopped nuts in the topping for extra crunch and a hearty finish. The cake is usually baked in a round tin and cut into wedges, much like a scone or soda bread, adding to its country-style charm.
This cake pairs wonderfully with a dollop of whipped cream, a drizzle of vanilla custard, or even a spoonful of yogurt. Its slightly tart, slightly sweet profile makes it versatile enough to enjoy with breakfast coffee or as a satisfying end to dinner. It’s the kind of cake that tastes just as good the next day, perhaps even better, making it a great option for making ahead.
Irish apple cake is more than a dessert; it’s a celebration of simple ingredients and timeless tradition. With each bite, you get the feeling of a warm kitchen, a family table, and a recipe passed down through generations.

Ingredients
- 500 g apples preferably Granny Smith, peeled, cored, and sliced
- 250 g all-purpose flour sifted
- 1 tsp baking powder
- 125 g sugar
- 1/2 tsp ground cinnamon
- 1/4 tsp ground nutmeg
- 125 g unsalted butter cold and diced
- 1 large egg beaten
- 3-4 tbsp milk
- 2 tbsp granulated sugar for sprinkling
Instructions
- Preheat your oven to 375°F (190°C) and grease a 9-inch round cake tin.
- In a large mixing bowl, combine flour and baking powder, then rub in the cold diced butter until the mixture resembles breadcrumbs.
- Add sugar, cinnamon, and nutmeg to the flour mixture, and mix well.
- Stir in the sliced apples, ensuring they are completely coated with the flour mix.
- Mix the beaten egg with enough milk to make the wet ingredients up to 150ml. Add to the flour and apple mix and stir to a thick batter.
- Pour the batter into the prepared cake tin, spreading it evenly, and sprinkle the top with granulated sugar.
- Bake in the preheated oven for 50 minutes or until a skewer inserted in the center comes out clean.
- Allow the cake to cool in the tin for about 10 minutes before transferring to a wire rack to cool completely.
- Serve warm or at room temperature, ideally with a drizzle of custard or cream.
It was okay, but my oven doesn’t heat right. Took forever to bake and I burned the bottom. Should’ve checked it sooner!
So easy! My kids loved it, too. I just wish there was a bit more spice. Next time I might add more cinnamon! 🥰
This cake is absolutely delicious! I used a mix of apples and it turned out perfect. Will make again for sure! 😋
I don’t really get why everyone loves this cake. It was kinda bland and the apples were mushy. Maybe I messed up? 🤔
Bland? Really? I loved it! You might have missed a step or maybe your apples weren’t sweet enough? Either way, keep experimenting!
I totally agree! I’ve made it a few times, and sometimes it comes out too mushy for my liking too. Maybe try a different apple variety next time? 😊
I don’t know why you’d put nutmeg in cake. I don’t like the flavor.
Pretty good, but should have added more sugar. My kids didn’t like it 🙁
I agree! A bit more sugar would make it sweeter. My kids love cakes that are super sweet. Maybe you could try adding a glaze next time?
More sugar? I think it was fine as is. Kids can be picky sometimes. Maybe they were just not in the mood for cake? 🤷♂️
Been lookin for an Irish recipe! I think I can handle this one.
Seems easy, but I’m not sure about baking. Can anyone confirm it’s good?
This looks delish! I wanna try it this weekend. 🍏🍰
This cake is fantastic! The apples keep it so moist. Definitely a keeper! 🍏
I totally agree! The apples really do make a difference. 🍰
Terrible. Mine came out gummy in the center even after 50 minutes. I might’ve underbaked or messed the oven temp (my oven runs hot).
Sorry that happened! This recipe is a bit apple-heavy, so if the center stayed gummy, it’s often underbaking or the apples released extra moisture. I’d try baking 10–15 minutes longer and checking with a skewer—if it’s wet with apple bits, give it more time.
Mine was dry and perfect at 375°F, so maybe your oven temp is off. If your oven runs hot, you should drop the temp a bit (like 360°F) or use an oven thermometer. Also did you dice the butter and mix until breadcrumb stage?
Tried making it gluten-free… didn’t work out. Maybe stick to original?
Custard on top is mandatory. Otherwise it’s just a cake. Sorry but that’s how I feel 😅
I tried this, but it turned out super dry. Maybe I did something wrong? 🤔
I tried this recipe, but my cake came out too dry. What did I do wrong?
The sugar sprinkle on top made a nice crust. I’m calling it Irish *because* of the apples and vibes. 😅
It was okay, but I’ve made better apple cakes before. A bit bland for my taste.
Ugh I used the wrong tin size (8-inch) and it came out thicker in the middle, still tasty though. Would definitely reduce the bake time if you go smaller.
Not sure about the butter “breadcrumbs” step—mine stayed a little clumpy. Ended up fine, but texture wasn’t as light as I hoped.
Looks good but my cake didn’t rise. Not sure what I did wrong.
I followed the recipe but mine turned out too dry. Maybe I overmixed? Not sure what went wrong.
Okay, but what is custard?? Does it make the cake? Maybe I’ll try next time with ice cream instead.
Custard is a creamy sauce made from milk and eggs. It’s super yummy on desserts! But ice cream sounds good too, whatever works for you!
I found it a bit too sweet for my taste. Maybe less sugar next time?
I totally get you! It’s always hard to balance sweetness, especially with apples. Less sugar sounds good! 🍏
Apple cake? More like apple disaster! 😩
I made this and it turned out amazing! Don’t give up on it, you may have done something wrong 😄
I don’t get why it’s called Irish Apple Cake? It’s just cake with apples to me. But hey, flavor-wise it works.
I was skeptical about the breadcrumb texture, but it actually works. Mine took closer to 55-60 min to get the skewer clean. Still delicious with a little cream.
Irish? Is that like… Irish cream or something? 🤔
Very good, but a bit too sweet for my taste – I’d reduce the sugar next time.
I totally agree! It was a bit sweet for me too. Reducing the sugar sounds like a solid plan.
Too much sugar! I cut it down to half but still was sweet. Maybe cut out the sprinkle too?
Isn’t this supposed to be more spongy? I feel like I messed it up. 😕
YUM! I added raisins and loved it even more!
This cake is too hard to make. Who has time to grate apples?! Why don’t you just buy a cake from the store?
Really simple to make. The spices smell amazing while baking!
So good, I had to share with my neighbor lol!
Yummy! Used some honey instead of sugar and added walnuts. Delicious twist! Will make again for sure.
The breadcrumb step is weirdly satisfying. I was worried it would be too dry, but the egg + milk got it to a nice thick batter.
Yes!! The breadcrumb texture is my favorite part—like a quick shortcut to a tender crumb. Mine came out perfectly moist with the egg + just a few tbsp of milk.
I was skeptical at first because I’ve messed up other cakes by over-wetting, but the instructions here make sense. I used more milk than the recipe said though and it got a bit heavy—still tasty, just not as nice.
The crumbly/breadcrumb stage with the cold butter is genius. I was skeptical at first but it bakes up nicely—almost like a cross between cake and shortbread.
Yes!! The cold butter + breadcrumb texture is the secret. I was worried it would be dry, but the apples totally make it tender.
I think 50 minutes is a little optimistic for my oven. I had to go closer to 60 before the skewer came out clean.
Should’ve baked 5-10 minutes longer. Center was a little gummy, but once I gave it extra time it was actually delicious.
Not bad, but 50 minutes wasn’t enough for my oven. Also I forgot to sprinkle the extra sugar and it looked less golden. Still tasted good though.
Could be better. Mine didn’t set right and was mushy.
Maybe you used too much milk? I followed the recipe and it turned out perfect!
Chef tip: use Granny Smith like it says—wow. Tart apples make the sweetness behave. Custard drizzle was essential.
Yes!! I used Granny Smith and the cake tasted way less cloying—totally agree about the tartness balancing the sweetness. Also the custard drizzle really makes it feel “bakery” level. Thanks!
I followed the steps but mine came out a bit dense. Maybe I overmixed after adding the egg?
Dense usually means too much flour got activated or the batter got worked a lot. Also check your apples—if they were super wet or extra sliced thin, they can weigh it down. Try thicker slices and mix the apples in lightly.
Totally possible. Once the egg goes in, I try to mix just until everything looks combined—overmixing can make it dense. Next time, do a few gentle stirs and stop.
What apples do I use? Green/red? Does it matter?
You should really use Granny Smith apples! They give the cake a nice tart flavor. Red apples are too sweet for it, I think.
Just made this and burnt it, now I got a rock instead of cake. Never again!
Yummm! So easy and delicious! I had it with ice cream!
This cake was so delightful! The apples were perfect and the spices were just right. Definitely a keeper!
I’m so glad you loved it! This cake has become my go-to for fall gatherings. The flavor is just unbeatable!
Looks good, but I wonder if using more sugar would make it better? Or maybe a chocolate version?! 😛
This cake turned out amazing! So moist and delicious. My kids loved it!
5 stars! Made this for my family and they all loved it. Will make again for sure!
This is a very no-fuss cake. I love that you coat the apples in flour—prevents sinking (unlike some other apple bakes I’ve tried).
I don’t have a cake tin, can I just use a baking pan? 🤔
I dunno, isn’t a cake tin supposed to help with the shape? What if it flattens out?
Yeah, you can use a baking pan! Just make sure to adjust the baking time a bit. 😁
Easy to make! I used different apples and it was still really good. Will make again!
I’m skeptical about the baking powder. Doesn’t seem like enough for a cake this size. Anyone else think so?
I tried this but it turned out too dry. Maybe I didn’t add enough milk? I think my apples were too old too.
Yesss!!! Love this recipe 🥰🥰🥰
Made this yesterday—so cozy and the apples stay nice and tender. I used a mix of Granny Smith and Honeycrisp and it still worked perfectly.
This cake is amazing! Just like my grandma used to make. I added a pinch of cloves for extra flavor!
I added walnuts for crunch. Change the flavor a bit but it’s still good!
Mine was kinda dry, maybe I overbaked or my apples were too thick. Tasted fine though—just not as soft as I hoped. Next time I’ll slice thinner and keep an eye on it.
Dry?? Dang. I feel like 50 min is too long for some ovens. Maybe your Granny Smith were really firm too. Next time try mixing in a tiny splash more milk/butter or cover with foil halfway.
Good call on the thickness—mine got a little dry once when the apple slices were chunky. I now slice pretty thin and pull it as soon as the skewer is clean (ovens run hot!).
Yummy!! 😍
This was way too dry for my liking. I added extra butter but still didn’t work.
I had the same issue when I made it! Maybe the apple type makes a difference? I used Braeburn, and it turned out great.
Perfect recipe! My family loved it! I used different apples though… hope that’s okay?
I followed the recipe but mine came out super dry, any tips?
Maybe try adding more milk next time? It could help with the moisture. Good luck!
The instructions were confusing, what is a skewer?? Is it a stick or what?
Lol, just a stick?? Really? I thought it was something fancy! But I guess it’s just a stick then. Thanks for clearing that up!
A skewer is basically just a stick that you use to check if the cake is done. You stick it in the middle, and if it comes out clean, the cake is ready! Don’t worry, it’s a common term in baking.
Horrible! My cake collapsed in the oven! What did I do wrong?
I followed everything, even weighed the butter and apples, and it still came out kinda dense. Maybe my apples were too watery? Not sure, but it wasn’t my favorite.
I don’t like nutmeg, can I leave it out? Or does it change the whole flavor?
I followed it exactly and it came out dense, like a heavy shortcake. Could be my flour (or overmixing).
Is Granny Smith apples really the best for this? I used red ones by mistake and it worked fine!
Nah, doesn’t matter much. Apples are apples, right? Just bake it!
I think Granny Smiths are preferred for their tartness, but if red apples worked for you, that’s awesome! Every oven is different!
Delicious and easy to make! My family loved it. Will definitely make again.
Pretty straightforward recipe. I used Honeycrisp apples instead of Granny Smith and it was still delicious, just sweeter. Next time I’ll chill the butter a bit longer for a better crumbly texture.
This cake is amazing! The apples are so juicy and the spices are perfect! Definitely a keeper! 🥰
I forgot to grease the tin and it stuck a bit… my bad. But the flavor is legit. I’m giving it a decent score anyway.
Oof, been there 😅 But honestly if the flavor still came through, that’s what matters. I’m glad it turned out tasty for you!
Stuck a bit? Next time butter + flour the tin, not just grease. Still… 50 min at 375F sounds a touch long/short depending on your apples. Mine usually needs a few more minutes. Flavor though? nice!
This cake is too sweet for me. I guess I should’ve added less sugar.
I don’t get why people rave about this. It came out way too dense for me.
The nutmeg was too strong for my taste. Next time I’ll use less. 😣
My grandma used to make a similar cake when I was a kid. Brought back memories!
That’s so sweet! There’s nothing like a recipe that brings back childhood memories. Can’t wait to try it myself!
Looks good, but my grandma’s recipe was way different. She added raisins and used walnuts too!
just great!!! baked in my kitchen and family loved it 🙂
Delish! I added oats for some crunch. Will make again for sure!
That sounds great! Oats are a nice touch. I might try that next time too!
Oats? Really? I thought this was a cake… Isn’t that weird?
meh. Was horrible tbh. it didn’t taste like anything and the texture was mushy. would not recommend.
I tried this recipe but it came out way too dry. Did I miss something?
Baking times vary so make sure to check it multiple times!
Absolutely! I always check my cakes every 10 minutes. Better safe than sorry!
Why do you have to check? Just set the timer and forget it. I did that last time and it was burnt!
Yummy! I added some raisins because why not? Turned out amazing!
The nutmeg + cinnamon combo is spot on. I didn’t have enough milk so I added a splash more apple juice… turned out slightly sweeter but still great.
DID YOU SAY APPLE CAKE? YES PLEASE!!!!
Could you bake it longer? Mine was gooey inside. I like my cake cooked all the way!
Why use Granny Smith apples? Can’t I use any apple? I used Fuji, still turned out nice!
Made this last weekend and wow—super cozy. The cinnamon + nutmeg smelled amazing while baking. I used Honeycrisp apples and it still worked great.
Yes!! Honeycrisp apples are perfect for this kind of cozy cake—glad it still worked out. Did you taste more cinnamon or more apple sweetness?
Meh. Too much effort for an apple cake. Also my oven ran hot so it got a little dark. Won’t lie, I expected more.
5 stars just for the smell. My kitchen smelled like a bakery for hours. My kids ate it warm with custard.
Easy to follow recipe, but I feel like oven temps vary. Mine came out slightly burnt on the edges.
The apples hold up nicely after baking. I used Honeycrisp and it was sweeter than expected, but still great.
Good to hear! I’ve got some Honeycrisp too—next time I’ll probably cut the sugar a bit so it’s not overly sweet.
I only had self-rising flour and still tried it. Tbh it was too much lift and weird texture… won’t do that again.
I used a mix of apples and added raisins. So good!!
I don’t like nutmeg. Can I leave it out? Cake still taste good?
It came out a bit dense and I think I overmixed the batter. Still edible, but not that light cakey texture I was hoping for. Would try again carefully.
I followed the steps exactly and it turned out really tender. Next time I’ll toss the apples with a tiny bit more cinnamon/sugar so every bite tastes like apple pie.
Pretty easy directions, I just couldn’t get the “breadcrumbs” texture the first time—still tasted good though. Next batch I’ll chill the butter longer.
This is giving ‘farmhouse cake’ vibes, in a good way. I didn’t even have nutmeg so I used extra cinnamon—still decent.
Followed the steps exactly, but my center took longer than 50 minutes. Still tasted incredible though—would bake a bit longer next time.
I love that it still turned out great for you! 🙌 For my oven, it usually needs closer to 55–60 minutes depending on how juicy the apples are. Next time, just keep an eye on it and go by the skewer test—sounds like you already nailed the flavor.
Maybe your oven runs hot/cold? If the center was taking longer, I’d cover the top with foil after ~30 minutes so it doesn’t overbrown while the middle finishes. Also, did you cut the apples really thin? thicker pieces can slow it down. It’s still an “Irish” cake though, so more time is probably fine 😅
Not sure about the 3–4 tbsp milk instruction—my batter barely came together until I used more. Maybe my apples were juicier?
Yum! Just made this and it’s literally the best apple cake I’ve ever tasted. Thank you!
What’s with the nutmeg? Does it really make such a difference? I’ve never used it before.
I’m skeptical about the crumbly flour/butter step, but it actually works. Texture was somewhere between cake and pastry. Not too sweet, which I liked.
Honestly didn’t taste much cinnamon to me, but my spices are probably old. The texture was good and the apples stayed nicely soft.
I found it a bit bland. Perhaps it needs more sugar? I added some raisins, but still not my favorite.
This is the best apple cake recipe I’ve ever tried! So moist and flavorful. My family loved it!
Really? I found it kinda dry. I think I might’ve overbaked it. 🤔
I’m so glad you loved it! It’s honestly my go-to recipe for gatherings. Everyone always asks for seconds!
This cake was amazing! So moist and flavorful. Family devoured it in one sitting. 5 stars!
Wow, it must be really good! I’ll have to try it. Is it that easy to make? I’m not the best baker 😂
I’m so glad to hear that! I made it too, but my family didn’t like it as much. Maybe I did something wrong? 😢
Why 375°F? I always struggle with temps from recipes. Mine browned too fast on top—next time I’ll tent it with foil. Taste was fine though.
Yummy!! But I use different apples. It still good. Maybe not as good as yours but close.
Not traditional Irish apple cake. I thought there’d be more spices like in a pie. Disappointed!
Just okay. I think my grandma’s recipe is better. 😒
Pretty good. But I feel like it needed more spice, maybe some cloves or ginger too?
I totally agree! A pinch of cloves would really boost the flavor! Gonna try that next time! 👍
More spice? I don’t know, this recipe seems good as-is. Too much might ruin it!
Yum! I love this cake! It’s like a hug from my grandma.
I totally agree! This cake definitely brings back memories of family gatherings and warm desserts. So comforting!
Mmmm, so good! Made it for my tea time and it vanished.
This is giving me ‘afternoon tea’ vibes 😂. The apple pieces are the star. I served it with custard and everyone asked for the recipe.
This is giving “cozy” vibes for real. The top sugar crunch is underrated.
How many apples should be put in the cake? Like 3 or 4?
I don’t have a wire rack so I just let it cool on the counter… and it got slightly soggy on the bottom. Flavor was still great.
Happens to me too—cooling on the counter traps steam. If you don’t have a rack, try flipping it onto a plate halfway through cooling or cooling on a folded towel so air can get underneath.
I used different apples and it turned out fine! Just make sure to adjust sugar if they’re sweet.
I followed it mostly, but my batter seemed way too thick before it hit the oven. I added an extra splash of milk and it turned out fine—maybe my egg was smaller?
This recipe reads simple but the timing is everything. Also, 375°F is 350°C right? (kidding). Still, nice cake!
Honestly I expected it to be lighter? It’s more dense than I wanted, and the flour coating on apples is kinda thick.
I baked at 375°F and it browned fast—maybe my oven runs hot. I covered it loosely with foil after 30 minutes to prevent burning.
So delicious!!! 😍 I used a mix of apples and added some walnuts. Yum!
That sounds amazing! Walnuts are a great idea! 😋
I don’t understand why people swear by apples in cake. This was too mushy for my taste. Not a fan!
Not as flavorful as I expected, maybe needs more spice.
I know what you mean! I added extra cinnamon and it was much better! Give that a try next time.
This cake is fantastic! I love the combo of apples and spices. My family devoured it!
This is the first apple cake I’ve made that doesn’t collapse. Maybe because the butter crumb + egg/milk balance is on point. Will make again.
Too sweet! Can’t believe u put that much sugar in. 🙄
I actually think the sugar is just right! The apples add tartness. Maybe you just don’t have a sweet tooth?
This is the only apple cake my boyfriend will eat, so yeah… big win 😅 I did the custard drizzle and it made it taste fancy.
This cake is amazing! My family loved it!
I followed it pretty closely, but mine needed closer to 60 minutes. Still delicious though—warm with custard is elite.
Nice! I’ve found apples can really change bake times—mine usually runs closer to 55–60 too. Custard with it is the best part 😄
I tried making this but used too many apples and now it’s a soggy mess. Oops!
Soggy mess? How’d that happen? I thought more apples = more flavor? 🤔
It’s all about balance! Maybe try less apples next time, or use a firmer variety? Don’t worry, cooking is a learning process! 😊
Yum! Perfect with cream, everyone enjoyed it!
Made this last weekend—so cozy. The cinnamon-nutmeg combo is perfect and the apples stay nice and tender. I used a bit less milk since my egg was smaller and it still turned out great.
Totally agree—this cake is *so* cozy. The cinnamon + nutmeg combo with tender apples is such a win. Nice call on using less milk too!
Hmm, I haven’t tried it with Granny Smith. I usually use Honeycrisp so they stay sweet—would that mess up the tender texture? Either way, glad yours turned out great!
Delicious and easy to make. The smell of apples and cinnamon was heavenly.
Sounds nice, but doesn’t apple cake need more sugar? Just 125g seems low to me.
I made this for my family and they loved it! So easy and yummy. Thanks for sharing!
Made this for my family and it smelled amazing. The apple coating step is key—mine came out tender and not too sweet. Would absolutely bake again.
Hmm I tried it once and my center wasn’t fully done at 50 min, so I baked like 10 more. Still tasted good though. Did you bake with a fan/convection or regular bake?
Made this for my family too—your apple-coating tip is spot on! Ours came out tender and fragrant, not overly sweet. Will 100% bake again.
I used slightly sweet apples (not Granny Smith) and it tasted kind of flat. Next time I’ll stick to the tart ones like the recipe says.
Totally makes sense—sweet apples can go kinda mushy and less “bright.” I’ve done it with Honeycrisp once and it felt bland too. Tart Granny Smith really does make the flavors pop here.
Hmm I’ve used sweet apples before and it was still good—maybe you needed more cinnamon or a splash more lemon? “Flat” could also be from not baking quite long enough? I don’t always stick to Granny Smith lol.
Really good but mine didn’t brown much at 50 min. I ended up adding like 10 more minutes. Also, 375°F is a little vague for my oven—next time I’ll check earlier with a toothpick.
Thanks for the tip! Mine also tends to be a little slow to color—adding time makes sense. I always check earlier with a skewer anyway.
The instructions are pretty clear, but ‘wet ingredients up to 150ml’ confused me. I just used 4 tbsp milk and it seemed fine.
Made this today and it smells amazing. The spices are perfectly cozy, and the apples actually stay juicy. I baked mine 5 minutes longer just to be safe—came out great.
Not sure about the nutmeg amount—felt a touch strong to me, but maybe I’m just sensitive. Would do 1/8 tsp next time.
I think you’re right to trust your palate—1/4 tsp nutmeg can read stronger depending on how fresh yours is. 1/8 tsp next time sounds perfect.
Umm I think it’s missing salt? i add a pinch and it helps. Otherwise it’s ok.
I thought the spices would be too much, but it’s balanced. Granny Smith really helps with that tart bite.
This cake is delicious! The apples made it so moist. Definitely a keeper! 🍏❤️
This is good but kinda simple? Like, no fancy icing and not very “Irish” in my mind. Still, apples make it hard to mess up.
Not a fan. Too much cinnamon for my taste. Can we cut back on that?
5 stars but also… am I supposed to slice the apples thin thin? Mine were kinda chunky and it was more like apple pudding cake lol. Still good though.
Not gonna lie, 9-inch tin maybe too small? Mine overflowed slightly even though I spread it evenly. Taste is good though.
Made this today—so cozy. The cinnamon + nutmeg with the Granny Smith apples is perfect. Mine took closer to 55 minutes, but the skewer test saved it!
Totally agree—cinnamon + nutmeg with tart apples is such a cozy combo. I also needed a few extra minutes and the skewer trick definitely saved me.
Mine came out kinda dense, but I think I overmixed the batter. Did you use Granny Smith for sure? 55 min seems about right though.
The nutmeg amount might be too low? I tasted more cinnamon than nutmeg. If you love nutmeg, I’d double it. Otherwise it’s okay.
Good flavor (cinnamon + nutmeg is perfect), but I think my batter was a bit too thick. I added an extra splash of milk and it turned out okay. Not bad for a weekday bake.
Made this last weekend and it turned out really moist and fragrant. The cinnamon + nutmeg combo is perfect with the tart apples.
Made this for tea and it turned out wonderfully moist—those Granny Smith apples are doing the heavy lifting. The cinnamon + nutmeg combo is perfect.
I added a splash more milk because the batter seemed too thick. Turned out moist and tender, and the top sugar crust was nice.
Not bad, but I found it a bit dry after cooling. I think my apples were juicier than expected, so maybe more milk or a shorter bake time would help.
I was worried 250g flour for 500g apples would be too little, but it held together. Still, I had to add a splash more milk to get it to “thick batter.”
Interesting! I used a slightly bigger apple volume and my batter was way too dry. I think the “150ml” wet target matters—next time I’ll measure instead of eyeballing.
Same here—250g flour sounded low, but the apple batter actually set nicely. I also needed a touch more milk to get that thick, spoonable consistency.
Granny Smith are expensive where I live, so I used regular apples. It was okay, but the flavor felt less “bright” and the cake didn’t rise as well.