Butternut squash risotto is the kind of dish that wraps you in warmth and comfort from the first bite. Rich, creamy, and subtly sweet, it’s a satisfying meal that feels elegant yet rustic. Smells like home. The natural sweetness of roasted butternut squash blends beautifully with the creamy texture of Arborio rice, while savory broth and a touch of Parmesan tie everything together into a bowl of pure comfort.
What makes this risotto stand out is the balance of flavor and texture. Butternut squash, when roasted or sautéed, becomes tender and slightly caramelized, offering depth and a hint of sweetness that plays perfectly against the savory, creamy rice. The risotto base itself is made by slowly adding warm broth to Arborio rice, allowing it to absorb gradually and release starch that creates that signature silky texture.
Garlic, shallots, or onions often serve as the aromatic foundation, adding a savory base that enhances the richness of the dish. Fresh herbs like sage or thyme bring a fragrant, earthy note that complements the squash and gives the risotto a seasonal touch. A finishing stir of butter and grated Parmesan adds richness and brings everything together in a velvety finish.
Butternut squash risotto is versatile enough to serve as a main course or a luxurious side dish. It pairs wonderfully with roasted chicken, pork, or a crisp green salad if you’re keeping things light. You can also customize it by adding toasted walnuts, goat cheese, or even a drizzle of balsamic glaze for a little contrast.
Whether you’re cooking for a cozy dinner at home or hosting a fall gathering, butternut squash risotto is a dish that feels both nourishing and special. It celebrates seasonal ingredients while offering a creamy, satisfying experience in every bite – perfect for cool nights and warm kitchens.

Ingredients
- 1 cup Arborio rice
- 2 cups Butternut squash cut into cubes
- 1 Onion chopped
- 1 clove Garlic minced
- 4 cups Vegetable broth kept warm
- 1/2 cup White wine optional
- 1/2 cup Parmesan cheese grated
- 2 tablespoons Olive oil
- 1 teaspoon Salt to taste
- 1/2 teaspoon Black pepper freshly ground
- 1 tablespoon Butter optional
Instructions
- Heat olive oil in a large pot over medium heat.
- Add chopped onion and cook until translucent, about 5 minutes.
- Add minced garlic and cook for another minute.
- Stir in Arborio rice and cook for 2 minutes, until rice is lightly toasted.
- Pour in white wine (if using) and cook until mostly absorbed.
- Begin adding warm vegetable broth, one ladle at a time, stirring constantly and allowing each addition to be absorbed before adding the next.
- After 15 minutes, add butternut squash cubes to the pot. Continue adding broth and stirring.
- After about 20 minutes, when the rice is tender and the squash is cooked through, stir in grated Parmesan cheese.
- Season with salt and freshly ground black pepper to taste.
- If desired, stir in a tablespoon of butter for extra creaminess.
- Serve hot, garnished with additional Parmesan cheese if desired.
My family loved it but I left out the wine. Still turned out tasty! Gonna make this again.
I dunno, risotto without wine seems weird. Isn’t the wine part of what makes it creamy? 🤔
That’s awesome! I bet the butternut squash added a nice sweetness. Can’t wait to try it without wine! 😋
This was so good! I never thought I’d love squash this much. The creaminess is just perfect.
I don’t think risotto is supposed to be this watery. I did everything right but ended up with soup! What went wrong?
Whaaaaat? Risotto takes too long to cook! I don’t have time for that. I just eat it from a box instead.
Who has the time tho? Ain’t nobody got time to stir for 20 mins! Boxed is just easier, and it still tastes okay.
I get that cooking can be time-consuming, but homemade risotto is worth it! You can make it ahead and enjoy it later. Plus, no box can match the flavor of fresh ingredients! 😊
Can I use any other type of squash? Because I don’t have butternut at home.
I’m not a big fan of butternut squash, but I was surprised how good this tasted. Will make again!
I tried it without the wine and it was still good! Don’t let the fancy stuff scare ya.
I skipped the white wine (didn’t have any) and it still tasted fine, just a little less “restaurant.” Also, 1 cup Arborio feels small for the amount of broth—still worked though.
This looks super cozy. I love that you keep the broth warm and add it ladle-by-ladle—classic risotto method. Gonna try with homemade veg broth!
Made this last night—so cozy. I kept the broth warm like the instructions say and the rice turned out perfectly creamy. The butternut squash sweetness is honestly the whole vibe.
Yes!! Cozy is exactly it. I made this too and the creamy texture is spot on when you keep the broth warm and stir like you mean it.
I don’t get why people love risotto. It’s just rice, isn’t it?
Is it really risotto if you don’t use chicken broth? Just sayin’… But this was still okay.
Risotto isn’t just chicken broth, it’s the technique! Butternut squash is a great choice, I dunno why you mad.
I think it can be risotto without chicken broth! The veggie broth gives it a nice flavor too. But I get your point. Still, this one was delicious!
I followed the recipe, but it turned out mushy. Not great. Maybe I did something wrong?
This is legit, but why do I have to stir it so much? It’s too much work for my regular dinners 😩
Absolutely delicious! The butternut squash adds a nice sweetness. I could eat this every week!
Butternut squash? Isn’t that a bit… odd for risotto? I’m not sure how it would taste, honestly.
I agree! The sweetness from the squash is just perfect. I made this last week and everyone loved it!
I tried making this, but the rice was too thick. What did I do wrong? Anyone else had this issue?
Ok recipe, but I feel like there’s too much stirring involved. Just make it simple next time! 😩
Easy peasy! I love how the squash adds color. Looks pretty on the plate. Skill level: amateur.
This was way too much work for a bowl of rice! Took forever!
I’m skeptical about the wine. Can’t I just skip it? Can it still taste good?
You can totally skip the wine! It will still taste great. Just add a bit more broth if you want it to be extra rich.
I was skeptical about 2 cups of squash going in after 15 minutes, but it worked. Mine took a bit longer to get tender, so I added broth a little longer. Still delicious and way better than boxed risotto.
Wow, this is now my go-to comfort food! So cozy, especially for fall.
This risotto was amazing! Perfectly creamy and the butternut squash added a nice sweetness. Will definitely make this again!
I dunno, sounds kinda complicated with all those steps. Can’t you just boil the squash and mix it in? 😅
I totally agree! The butternut squash really does make it special. It’s like a warm hug in a bowl! 🍂
Delish! This was perfect for dinner and super easy! Will definitely be making it again!
I’m glad you loved it! This is one of my favorites too. The butternut squash adds such a nice flavor!
This recipe is fantastic! I made it for my family, and they loved it. So creamy!
Took me ages to cook this! Not sure if I will make it again. Not my favorite flavor combo.
Delish 😋! My family loved it! Even my kids who say they don’t like squash ate it! Will make again!
My family said it was restaurant quality. I added extra black pepper and some thyme because… why not. The creamy consistency is legit.
Pretty solid recipe. I did it exactly and it came out creamy, but mine was a tiny bit too thick by the time the squash was done—next time I’ll add a splash more broth at the end.
Thanks for the tip! I’ve had the same issue—by the time the squash gets tender it can get heavy. A little extra warm broth at the end fixed it for me too.
Too much butter! I followed the recipe, but it turned out greasy. Less is more.
I get what you mean! I also found it too greasy. Maybe skip the butter next time or just use a bit less.
Did it exactly as you said, but it turned out mushy. What did I do wrong?
This is culinary magic! Who would’ve thought to mix squash and rice? Genius! 🌟
Looks yummy. Butternut squash is too watery sometimes—anyone else notice that? I might roast it first next time.
I tried this recipe and it didn’t turn out right. The rice was too hard and the squash got mushy. Not a fan.
I followed it exactly but my rice didn’t get as tender as I wanted. Maybe I needed longer, or my cubes were too big. Still tasty though.
I’ve had that happen too—Arborio can be stubborn. I usually go closer to 25–30 minutes total and add broth gradually until it’s spoon-tender, not just “timed.” Cube size matters a lot.
Can’t wait to try this, but can I skip the wine? Not everyone drinks.
Absolutely, you can skip the wine! The risotto will still be delicious with just the broth. Enjoy!
I think it’s a bit weird to not use wine. Isn’t that like, a main thing for flavor? But you do you.
Flavor is good, but mine got a little too thick/slow to loosen. I think my broth wasn’t hot enough or I wasn’t stirring hard enough. Next time I’ll keep the heat steady.
Good point about the broth temp—warm/steaming broth really helps keep the risotto loose as it cooks. I also end up stirring a bit more than I think I need. 😅
This happened to me once too. My pot was on too low and it started to thicken fast. Next time I’ll keep the heat steady like you said.
I don’t get the hype about risotto. It’s just rice! Very average, won’t be making this again.
Simply the best! I added some spinach too and it was fantastic.
I followed the recipe, but the rice got a little mushy—probably I added broth too fast. Next time I’ll be stricter. Parmesan at the end saved it.
Totally agree—risotto is super picky about broth timing. “One ladle at a time” is not just a suggestion 😅 Glad Parmesan saved it though!
Not sure I did it wrong, but my rice turned out kinda grainy and the squash got mushy. Maybe I cut the cubes too small? Either way, flavor was good.
Hmm grainy rice usually means it wasn’t getting enough stirring / broth didn’t stay hot. I’d try adding broth a little slower and keep it at a steady simmer.
Yum! Made this for my family and they loved it! Easy to make and tastes like a restaurant meal. 🙌
Why Arborio rice? Can’t I just use regular rice? I used jasmine rice instead, and it cooked differently but still edible!
I personally think Arborio really makes a difference! Jasmine rice is nice, but it’s not as creamy. But glad it turned out edible for you!
Honestly, who cares? Rice is rice! Sometimes I just use whatever I have. As long as it taste good, right?
Why use white wine? It’s just a waste of money! More broth plz.
Come on, white wine really isn’t that expensive if you buy a decent one. Plus, it gives the dish a richness that broth alone can’t achieve!
I think the white wine adds a nice flavor that complements the squash. Broth is good too, but wine can be a game-changer! 😊
Yum yum! I added some chicken in there too, it was a hit! Thank u for sharing this!
Respectfully… 1 cup rice with 4 cups broth seems like not enough? I worried halfway through, but it turned out okay. Still, I’d keep extra broth on hand just in case.
I totally get the worry—risotto always feels like it *needs* more liquid at first. But with frequent stirring and letting each ladle absorb, the rice kind of “drinks” it down fast. Extra broth on standby is a great call.
Not gonna lie, 1 cup rice to 4 cups broth sounded low to me too. Glad you said it turned out okay though—maybe the squash + Parmesan add some extra moisture/creaminess.
Made it tonight and it was a hit. I used a splash more wine than called for and maybe extra parmesan too… no regrets 😄
Great directions—especially adding broth one ladle at a time. I used homemade veggie broth and it tasted restaurant-level.
Solid recipe, but 2 cups of squash felt a bit much for my pot—next time I’d use closer to 1.5 cups. Still super tasty though, and the Parmesan at the end makes it.
I actually love the ratio you mentioned but I’ll note: I usually wait to add the squash a bit later, otherwise it gets too soft. Still, Parmesan at the end is never a bad call.
Totally agree on the squash amount. I also thought 2 cups was a lot—mine turned out a little heavy. Next time I’ll try 1.5 and see if it stays creamier.
The ingredient list is solid, but I wish it mentioned whether to roast the squash first. I ended up sautéing it a little and that helped the flavor a lot.
Totally agree—whether to roast the squash makes a huge difference. Roasting really brings out that caramelized flavor. I’m adding a step next time.
Easy recipe, but didn’t like the texture of the risotto. Too much stirring.
I forgot to add the cheese, and it wasn’t creamy at all. Note to self: read the instructions carefully!
Cheese is super important! Without it, what’s the point? But hey, maybe try again and pay more attention next time. 💁♂️
Don’t worry! It happens to the best of us. The important part is you learned from it. Just think of it as a rustic risotto now! 😊
So good, I’m salivating just thinking about it! Def a keeper!
I dunno, risotto seems too complicated to make. Why not just throw everything in a pot? 🤔
Absolutely! Risotto is the best, especially with squash! Can’t wait to try this recipe myself. 😋
I made this last night, it was kinda bland. Maybe more garlic next time?
Love butternut squash! This recipe is so easy and yum! 👌
Made it last night and it was honestly restaurant-level. My rice took a bit longer than 20 minutes, but once it turned creamy it was worth it. Parmesan at the end is the move.
Arborio rice + butternut squash is a combo I’m obsessed with. I used wine once and it was delicious, but honestly you can skip it and still be fine.
Yes!! Arborio + squash is such a cozy combo. I always add the wine anyway, but good to know it’s optional—sometimes I just forget to buy it 😅
I tried something similar with jasmine rice once and it turned out super gluey/undercooked. Arborio really makes a difference—your tip about skipping wine is helpful though.
This risotto is amazing! So creamy and flavorful. Will definitely make again!
I followed it exactly, except I forgot the butter at the end (oops). Still tasty though—maybe next time I’ll listen to the “optional” butter part.
Not gonna lie I messed up and added all the broth at once. It turned into something more like rice soup (still tasty though). Would probably be great if I weren’t chaotic lol.
Risotto? More like ‘Resist-o’! Couldn’t get it right 🤦♂️.
I totally get it! Risotto can be tough. Did you let the broth absorb enough? It took me a few tries too but it’s worth it in the end! 🍚
Pfft, it’s just warm rice and some veggies. Who needs all that fuss? 😒
Sounds fancy but it’s just rice n squash. Can we make it with brown rice tho? I like healthy food.
I’m not sure about the white wine part. Isn’t it a bit much for a veggie dish? I left it out and it turned out fine.
I always burn my risotto… this time it was perfect. I still don’t get the butter part. Isn’t it fatty?
Risotto? More like risk it-to! Wasn’t sure if I was doing it right but it turned out okay!
I added some chicken to mine for protein. Yummm! It was so good, my husband asked for seconds!
I dunno, chicken in risotto? Seems kinda weird, don’t it? But hey, if it works for ya!
That sounds delicious! Chicken is a great addition for flavor and protein. I’ll have to try it this way next time!
I tried it but my risotto never got truly “tender” after 20 minutes. I think my broth wasn’t hot enough? Also I forgot the wine and it was fine, just less depth.
5 stars cuz butternut squash is life. Also I used chicken broth instead and added more garlic… kinda turned out amazing, not gonna lie.
Butternut squash *is* life 😄 Glad the chicken broth + extra garlic worked out—risotto is so forgiving like that.
Wait, is butternut squash the same as pumpkin? I’m confused. Taste is okay though.
How can this be a recipe?! You just keep adding broth! Seems like cheating to me. 🙄
Risotto is overrated. I’d rather just roast the squash and eat it with rice.
I followed the recipe exactly and it came out a bit mushy. I think I added too much broth. Anyone else have that problem?
Meh, not for me. I like my rice less… mushy. Prefer fried rice any day!
Yum! Just yum! My kids devoured it too! Will make again! 🥰
This risotto is so creamy and delicious! I love the sweetness of the butternut squash. Definitely a keeper recipe!
Too rich for my taste. I think yall use too much cheese. 🤢
I kinda get what you mean, but the cheese really adds richness! You could try using less cheese or a different kind. 😊
Too much cheese? Nah, that’s the point of risotto! Just don’t add as much next time lol.
Great recipe! But why do you stir so much? Isn’t that just like extra work? LOL. Still tasted good!
I think stirring is key! It really helps the rice get creamy. Worth the effort for sure!
LOL, I know right? I got tired just reading the recipe! But maybe that’s why mine never turns out as good.
This risotto was sooo creamy! I didn’t use wine because I didn’t have any, but it still turned out great. My kids loved it!
Love this autumn vibe. Also, stirring constantly is kind of annoying, not gonna lie 😅 but it’s worth it.
Risotto is life! This recipe is pure comfort food. I added some spinach too and it was amazing! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
This is okay, but I feel like it’s missing something. Like it needs more salt/acid. Also, 4 cups broth for 1 cup rice sounds low? I ended up needing more. Still ate it all though.
Totally agree on the salt/acid part—risotto usually needs a little “snap.” I’ve started adding a tiny squeeze of lemon at the end and it wakes everything up.
4 cups broth for 1 cup rice *does* seem a bit on the low side depending on how firm you like it. I usually end up closer to 5–6 cups for arborio, especially with squash.
I’m skeptical about the white wine step—can’t really taste it in the end. But the risotto flavor is still good, so whatever.
Not sure if I did it wrong, but mine came out kind of thick and gummy. Maybe I didn’t stir enough or my rice wasn’t actually Arborio. Parmesan helped but it wasn’t quite right.
MMMMM So creamy! Plus, it’s super filling. Perfect for dinner. Totally recommend it!
2 questions: do you really need Arborio, and does the wine matter? I used regular rice and skipped the wine and it was kinda meh. Might try again but with more cheese.
Regular rice can work in a pinch, but it usually won’t turn out as creamy. For the wine—if you skip it, you may want to replace that acidity with a splash of lemon juice or extra broth, otherwise it can taste a bit flat.
Yes—Arborio really helps. It’s starchier, so you get that creamy, loose “risotto” texture instead of just rice with stuff. Wine adds acidity for balance, but it’s optional; your “meh” makes me think it needed more flavor/stock depth.
Did not taste like my grandmother’s risotto… no offense. I guess I expected more.
I get that! Sometimes nothing beats the old family recipes. My grandmas was the best too! But this one is still yummy in its own way.
5 stars. Very creamy 😋
Yesss that’s exactly how it should be! 😋 I always make sure to stir steady and use warm broth—results come out super creamy.
This recipe is delicious! I made it for my family, and everyone loved it. The flavors are amazing.
Good concept, but mine took longer than 20 minutes. Also I kept stirring like crazy and my arm is still mad at me. Still tasty though.
No matter what I do, risotto feels like a project. That said, this is one of the easier versions. I used frozen squash and it turned out fine. Parmesan at the end was the right move.
I dunno how to cook this fancy stuff, but I will try. Sounds too complicated though.
Idk risotto intimidates me. Like do you really have to stir constantly? I tried and it stuck a bit, but flavor was decent.
Not bad, but my risotto turned out kinda thick and I had to loosen it with extra broth. Maybe I didn’t absorb enough before adding the next ladle.
Yeah, that sounds like it needed a bit more liquid or more time letting each ladle absorb. Arborio can go from perfect to thick fast—next time just keep the broth warm and don’t rush the absorption step.
I don’t know, this seems too complicated for a regular dinner. Plus, I don’t like squash.
This recipe is AMAZING! The flavors are so rich and creamy. Can’t believe how easy it was to make.
Arborio rice can be tricky—if you overcook it, it gets mushy fast. I think 15 minutes before adding squash might be too long depending on your stove, but the flavor was great.
Took me forever to make, but it was delicious! My husband loved it, so worth it!
Arborio rice + constant stirring is a lot of work for dinner 😅. Don’t get me wrong, it tastes good, but I’m not sure it’s worth the effort compared to regular rice.
I followed the recipe, but mine turned out too mushy. What did I do wrong? 🤔
Lol I don’t have Arborio. Could I use long grain rice? Probably no, but worth asking. Either way, butternut risotto sounds amazing.
This turned out so creamy even without the butter! I followed the ladle-by-ladle method and the flavors really came together. The squash added a nice sweet, cozy vibe.
I’m not usually a risotto person, but the step-by-step helped. Stirring constantly is a workout 😂. Next time I’ll chop the squash smaller so it blends in better.
Lol “stirring constantly is a workout” is so real. I always end up with forearms of steel when I make risotto 😂
Mine was a little too thick after 20 minutes, but adding a splash more broth fixed it. Otherwise very solid flavor.
Butternut squash is yucky ??? But I guess some people like it. LOL!
Not sure about the amount of broth—4 cups for 1 cup rice is tight? Risotto usually drinks more. Might need extra if it’s not tender by the end.
I’ve made it with ~4 cups and it turned out fine for me, but I think it’s because I kept stirring and the broth was really hot. If you stop stirring or your broth isn’t warm, it’ll need more.
Good catch! With risotto style, 4 cups can be a little tight depending on your rice brand and how big the squash cubes are. I usually keep extra broth on hand—if it’s not tender yet, just add more warm broth.
I’m not usually a risotto person but this was honestly easy. Stirring constantly is the only part that’s a little annoying, though—like my arm got a workout.
Totally agree—once you get into that rhythm of ladling and stirring, it’s surprisingly straightforward. The arm workout is real though 😅
I mean… risotto is still risotto, you gotta babysit it. But I’ll say this one sounds less fussy than some. Did you use the wine? I always skip and it turns out fine.
This turned out so creamy even without the full butter! The squash sweetness really balances the Parmesan. I’ll make it again for sure.
This risotto was amazing! So creamy and flavorful! Definitely a keeper! 😊
Honestly? Mine came out kind of thick and gluey. I probably didn’t add the broth slowly enough or I overcooked it while waiting for the squash. The Parmesan helped but texture was off.
Good flavor, but my risotto took longer than 20 minutes. I think my broth was a bit too salty. Next time I’ll add the squash a little earlier so everything finishes together.
Okay I tried something like this and it came out kinda soupy… but maybe I didn’t stir enough (or my pot runs hot). This recipe seems straightforward though.
I’m skeptical about the “stir constantly” part—my arm hurts just reading that 😅 But I kept stirring more often than usual and it still came out creamy.
I don’t see why you need wine. Can’t you use water instead? Seems silly to me. 🤷♂️
I think the wine adds a depth of flavor that water just can’t compete with! You should give it a try. 🍷
1 cup rice to 4 cups broth seems low? I added more and it was fine, but the directions felt a little tight. Could use a clearer total broth amount.
I added the Parmesan a bit early and it clumped… next time I’ll wait like the instructions say. Still edible, just not pretty.
The timing feels a little off though—15 minutes then squash, then only ~20 total? My squash usually takes longer. Still, I bet it’ll be good if the cubes are smaller.
This turned out super creamy even without the butter—love the step-by-step broth ladling. The butternut squash flavor really shines.
Arborio rice is key, but I made the mistake of rinsing it. So yeah, it didn’t get that creamy texture. But flavor was still nice—will try again without rinsing.
That makes total sense—rinsing usually washes off the surface starch that gives risotto its creaminess. Glad the flavor still came through though! Next time you’ll nail the texture.
Made this tonight—wow. The step-by-step broth ladles made it super creamy, and the squash flavor really shines. I used the white wine and it tasted restaurant-level.
This looks so cozy! I love risotto, and the butternut squash combo sounds perfect for fall. The step about adding broth one ladle at a time is key—can’t wait to try it.